Chapter4

不要问我为什么

Reading Notes: Chapter 4 "The Elements of Digital Humanities: Object, Artifact, Image, Sound, Space"

Introduction to Materiality and Digital Representation

This chapter examines how digital technologies are reshaping the study of core humanities "elements"—objects, artifacts, images, sound, and space. The authors argue that digitization paradoxically heightens our awareness of materiality even as it transforms physical objects into digital data. Walter Benjamin's concept of the "aura" of an original artwork is invoked to frame a key tension: while digital tools enable precise reproduction, they also risk distancing us from the unique presence of artifacts in time and space.

Objects and Artifacts in the Digital Realm

The chapter distinguishes between natural "objects" and human-created "artifacts," noting that digitization allows artifacts to be studied in unprecedented detail. For example, 3D modeling projects like the Smithsonian's fossil collection or the Petrie Museum's Egyptian artifacts enable interactive examination without physical access. The Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative (CDLI) exemplifies large-scale digitization, offering searchable access to hundreds of thousands of cuneiform tablets.

Such projects highlight a shift from isolated analysis to aggregated, comparative studies, though they also raise questions about the loss of tactile and contextual engagement.

The Visual and Aural Turn

Digital image analysis tools, like those used in the Parker Library on the Web project, allow scholars to examine manuscripts with greater precision than the naked eye permits.

These environments allow users to navigate historical sites diachronically, but the authors note the ethical and methodological challenges—such as the high cost of VR projects and the potential for digital models to oversimplify complex historical contexts.

Critical Reflection

Chapter 4 underscores a central paradox: digitization both preserves and displaces materiality. While digital tools democratize access to cultural heritage, they also mediate our relationship with the physical world. The authors advocate for a balanced approach—using digital methods to enhance traditional scholarship without losing sight of the embodied, contextual nature of humanities research. This chapter invites readers to consider how digital elements can complement, rather than replace, the tactile and experiential dimensions of humanistic inquiry.