Reading Note: Hard Times by Charles Dickens （the other chapters）

不要问我为什么

    Chapters 4 to 8 of Hard Times solidify the novel's central conflict between the cold, utilitarian world of Fact and the repressed, struggling world of Fancy and human emotion. This section powerfully develops the characters of Mr. Bounderby and Louisa, while introducing the tragic figure of Stephen Blackpool, who embodies the human cost of the system championed by Coketown's leaders.
    The character of Josiah Bounderby is fully unveiled in Chapter 4. Dickens masterfully exposes him as a hypocrite whose entire identity is constructed upon a myth of self-made success. His incessant boasts about his impoverished childhood—being born in a ditch and raised by a drunken grandmother—are presented not as inspiring humility but as a weapon to assert superiority and justify his harshness. His relationship with Mrs. Sparsit, the impoverished aristocrat he employs, highlights his perverse pride; he parades her as a trophy of his power to humble the high-born. However, his bluster cannot conceal his emotional illiteracy, especially in his interactions with Louisa, whom he views as a possession or a project rather than a person.
    This is most evident in Chapter 5, "The Key-note," where Dickens offers a devastating portrait of Coketown itself. The town is a "triumph of fact," a monotonous, polluted landscape where life is reduced to mechanical function. The description of the town's identical streets and the pistons of the engines working "monotonously up and down, like the head of an elephant in a state of melancholy madness" is a brilliant metaphor for the soul-crushing effect of this industrial system. The workers are dehumanized into "the Hands," a collective mass whose inner lives are ignored until they become a statistical problem of discontent or vice.
    It is against this bleak backdrop that Louisa's internal crisis deepens. In Chapter 7, "Mrs. Sparsit," and Chapter 8, "Never Wonder," we see the consequences of her father's education. Her famous confession to her brother Tom—"I am so tired… I have been tired a long time… I don’t know of what—of everything, I think"—is a cry of profound existential despair. She has been starved of imagination and emotion, leaving her with a "starved imagination keeping life in itself somehow." Her secret observation of the fire, in which she sees "a starved imagination keeping life in itself somehow," signifies a faint, guttering spark of Fancy that her upbringing has failed to extinguish completely. This spark makes her vulnerable and sets the stage for her future struggles.
    The introduction of Stephen Blackpool in Chapter 10 provides the human face to the suffering of Coketown's workers. Stephen is the antithesis of Bounderby: genuinely humble, kind, and morally steadfast. His personal tragedy—being trapped in a miserable marriage with a drunken wife—is a direct challenge to the Gradgrind-Bounderby philosophy. When he asks Bounderby for a way out of his marriage, he is coldly informed that divorce is a luxury for the rich, a "muddle" of the law that offers no escape for a poor man. Stephen's conclusion—"’Tis a muddle… ’Tis just a muddle a’together"—is one of the most powerful indictments in the novel. It acknowledges that the rigid, fact-based systems governing society are incapable of addressing complex human suffering, resulting in an unjust and incomprehensible "muddle" for those with no power or money.
    In summary, these chapters move the novel from establishing its philosophical thesis to exploring its human consequences. Through the contrasting figures of the bombastic Bounderby, the despairing Louisa, and the tragically noble Stephen, Dickens demonstrates that a world built solely on Fact and self-interest is not only dreary and oppressive but fundamentally cruel and incapable of fulfilling basic human needs for compassion, love, and justice.